Tuesday, August 28, 2012

Amsterdam and its Red Lights



not a prostitute





On Saturday night in Amsterdam I turned to Stephen and was all
"hey babe, want to go see some prostitutes?"
He hesitated, but then obliged...
such a good fiance.

Now before you get all,
I CANT BELIEVE YOU WENT TO SODOM AND GOMORRAH on me,
let me explain.

Prostitution is everywhere,
it may not be on as much display as in Amsterdam,
but it is worldwide.
One of the main contributors to the problem is those that keep the need for these "working" women alive,
and that is western men.
So whether we like it or not,
we encounter one or the other all of the time.
It is just easier to turn a blind eye to it in other parts of the world,
whereas in Amsterdam, it is right there in your face.

When I travel,
I love to immerse myself in the culture in a different way.
I am not really a museum go-er
(although the red light district could count as a museum...of sorts...)
and walking around historical monuments and castles sort of bores me.

I like to see what the locals see,
I like to know what is going on now,
and eat a lot of food in the process.

The Red Light district fascinates me..it is the psychologist in me. I can't help it.
It also makes me incredibly sad because you know most of those women are working as a result of being trafficked.

We all know about human trafficking,
I have good friends who work in the field to help save these girls who are being trafficked in the USA.


We can watch all of the documentaries on HBO we want and call ourselves aware,
but it is very different to see something like this in person.

I felt like I was walking through a Halloween exhibit or something,
not that the girls were scary looking,
in fact, they were actually quite stunning,
but tons of women behind individual glass windows/doors lit up with red back lighting,
trying to coax men to come to them,
was something straight out of a film.
Or just another Saturday night in any major city, minus the red rooms and money exchange..
Let's be honest,
girls dressed in little clothing trying to get guys to notice/sleep with them? 
Not exactly a foreign concept.


I also thought I would feel unsafe,
and I don't know if it is because my fiance is 6'5,
but I didn't feel the level of fear of getting hurt/stolen/robbed/or caught in the middle of a brawl as I thought I would in this area.
Most of the hundreds of people in the pretty jam-packed part of the city are young men
(a lot of American and British guys)
who are probably there on a stag night (bachelor party).
Surprisingly, there were a lot of women too (aside from the prostitutes, I mean)
and a lot of couples.
I am sure a lot of them were there because of the same curiosity that led S and I there.
But it is always wise to be careful, of course.

We got home and I researched the red light district.
How it started, how it has changed over the years.
Like I said,
I'm just fascinated by the whole thing.

And yes, the weed was plentiful.
We don't smoke,
but pretty sure it is possible to get a contact high.


Has anyone else been?
What was your reaction?
Would love you to share your experience in the comments for others, who havent been, to read.



*more on amsterdam tomorrow 


43 comments:

  1. My husband and I were there in May. I'm like you - I just like to get immersed in the culture. I was the one who asked my husband if we could go to the red light district, basically out of morbid curiosity. I was (uh, mistakenly) of the belief that it would be a glamorous, moulin rouge type of place. Not so much. All of the women looked bored out of their mind, and I was told that the perky, happy ones were the saddest story of all -- they were the ones who really NEEDED the business, because they were being trafficked and had to bring money back to their pimps.

    Anyway, I wrote a little about my thoughts here - http://werejustdandy.blogspot.com/2012/05/amsterdam.html

    Basically I agree, it was fascinating and a little sad. But honestly? I didn't find it as sad as Vegas, with guys on street corners passing out cards with girls' pictures on it. At least a lot of the women in Amsterdam are running their own business, making a living. It seems strange to us, but to them it's life, and maybe even something to be proud of.

    PS Did you find the Blue Light district??

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was also surprised by the red light district! The area its in is actually quite pretty with the canals and stuff and I expected there to be dirt and trash everywhere (I just don't think of clean and shiny when I think of prostitution) but I was totally wrong. I'm glad I gave in to my curiosity and checked it out. I was exploring Amsterdam by myself and didn't feel unsafe at all in that area though I didn't go at night so that made a huge difference.

    <3 Daryl
    Roots, Wings & Other Things
    $100 Anthropologie Giveaway

    ReplyDelete
  3. I haven't been to the red light district but I did live in an oil town in Africa which prostitution was rampant. Women would beckon my husband when I was with him, Western men had families at home in the US and another in Africa and I always felt so conflicted when I'd see a disgusting, fat old man with a young African girl on his arm and they didn't even speak the same language (aside from sex, of course.)
    I'm morbidly curious about the whole thing too - I think because it's so taboo where we come from.

    ReplyDelete
  4. haven't been to amsterdam but i want to. i'm like you, when in rome!!

    and i'm glad you clarified that YOU were not a prostitute in that picture.

    ReplyDelete
  5. That would be so hard for me to be there. Mainly because I would see all these women and know they were never given a chance for a better life, and that there was nothing I could do about it. You know what brought me so much awareness to this problem? The movie Taken. Sad that the movies is what had to inform me (with further research).

    The psychology behind situations like this totally fascinate me too.

    P.S. The photos are lovely

    ReplyDelete
  6. i am a prostitute and i support this message.

    tee hee hee

    xo the egg out west.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Yes, yes, and yes! This post reminds me SO much of our visit to Amsterdam this past spring...(here's my shameless plug of my Amsterdam blog posts - http://keepingupwiththecotes.blogspot.de/search/label/Amsterdam). ;) I'm not much of a museum goer either, so submerging myself in the culture and food is always top priority. And the Red Light District was HIGH on the list. No pun intended.

    We walked down to the RLD around 5pm on a Saturday afternoon and couldn't believe my eyes. I had NO idea the girls would be behind glass cases the way they were. Literally on display. Tons of bachelor parties were out hooting and hollering at the ladies...one woman in a tourist group tried to pull her camera out and take a photo and this man (pimp, I'm assuming?) ran out and took the camera out of her hand and yelled at her (guess you've gotta pay for EVERYTHING there)...and we may or may not have been propositioned by a transvestite walking in front of the live sex show. Seriously, what's not to love about the RLD? :)

    Oh and I'm positive you could get a contact high, too. That place is BA-NANAS.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I've never been to Amsterdam, but if I went I'm pretty sure that curiosity would also get the best of me and I would have to have a look for myself. That being said, I do think the whole situation is very sad and I feel sorry that there is a demand that drives this business in the first place. Human beings, we tend to be our own worst enemies ;/

    I'd also be interested in reading into its history.

    xxx
    Jenna

    ReplyDelete
  9. My experience in the redlight district reminded me a bit of going to the zoo. It didn't seem to me that most of the people milling around were actually in the market for some "lovin'" - it was more that we were all there just to gawk. For some reason, this made me even more sad for the girls - you know the people who are going to solicit services probably aren't wearing their judgy pants (or any pants), but the sight see-ers made me embarrassed for them. That probably makes no sense, but it's feeling that has really stuck with me.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You should watch the movie The Whistleblower. It's about human trafficking in Bosnia, I think. It's based on a true story. Very sad and eye opening.

    ReplyDelete
  11. It's the worlds oldest profession. I've considered it to really boost my income. What?

    ReplyDelete
  12. I haven't been, but I bet I would just to see it for the exact reasons you stated. And thank you for clarifying you're not a prostitute. I was like "Hot woman! Oh..."

    ReplyDelete
  13. I was supposed to go to Amsterdam while i was studying abroad in Spain and though the trip fell through i've still be intrigued by the red light district. i've heard mixed feelings from people who have seen it (it's dangerous, it's madness, it's cool and crazy), but i think from seeing movies like the whistleblower and documentaries of human trafficking in the US, i've wanted to learn more about it all.

    ReplyDelete
  14. There seems to be a completely different understanding between Americans and us Europeans as to what exactly the look of prostitution is or ought to be. As a Belgian (that little country west of the Netherlands), I have often visited Amsterdam and seen the RLD, and have found that it doesn't glorify prostitution nor demean the women working there. Antwerp and Brussels have the same kind of districts, where the women sit in front of tall windows and try to beckon the men that come by. But these districts also have at least one police station there, and a free house where the women can inform, educate and protect themselves, instead of having to wonder the streets and stop cars at night. Granted, most of the women there did not chose to be there, and often find it extremely difficult to get out.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I've never been anywhere prostitution is legal but I won't lie, if I did, I would totally want to check it out. It fascinates me but makes me sad at the same time.

    - Kendra thedarlingblog.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. I have been to Amsterdam before and found myself in the red light district. I was very young and found it creepy. I left very quickly.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I was equally fascinated/shocked/saddened/slightly horrified by it all. I had to eat lots of fries with mayo to get over it.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I was briefly in Amsterdam when I was 16, the summer before I started my junior year of high school. We were on a "school" trip, and we walked--rather quickly--through the red light district.

    I saw some really terrifying things for a 16 year old girl, and to be honest, I didn't think much about it beyond the fact that there were half naked women behind glass windows, shaking sex toys at us as we passed by. It's just too sad to even comprehend.

    ReplyDelete
  19. i have ever been to amsterdam but i think if i did go i would go the red light district out of curiosity just because it is so public over there while here it is all hidden away which can make it a lot more dangerous.

    at university i did a module on gender, crime and punishment which focussed on prostitution as one of its topics and what i learnt about it and human trafficking was eye opening and awful.

    ReplyDelete
  20. My brother went to Amsterdam a few years ago and his girlfriend told him that if he went to the Red Light District, she was going to basically break up with him. I talked to her several times and told her how ridiculous that was. Just because he walked through the Red Light District didn't mean he was going to go to a sex show or anything. It was just something you did in Amsterdam. She never lightened up. His hostel ended up being IN the Red Light District and when he got home, she was PISSED. Honestly, their relationship was never the same after that. So stupid.

    I find things like the Red Light District fascinating as well. It's just so crazy to think that people do that for a living. Weird.

    And I didn't realize Stephen was SO TALL. Holy cow. Tall drink of water.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I have to giggle at some of these comments. I lived in Amsterdam for a little bit and loved every second of it. It is an absolutely crazy-awesome city with MUCH MORE to offer than just the red light district. 90% of the folks to go to the red light district are tourists curious or out with a group for a stag night/whatever. The red light district is run like a business and those girls can hold their own. I have seen them throw piss on tourists for taking photos and not 'buying'.

    Amsterdam has a rich history and I highly suggest to anyone to GO and have a great time! Live it up! Get away from the touristy areas and go explore.

    Mucho love.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I've never been, but I would like to. I have very strong views on prostitution, and me, mum and my sister were talking about it a while ago, and the awqkward question, "Would you go to prostitution?" came up. I said never, but if I was so desperate, had no job, was starving then I probably would. Like many girls I suppose, they don't do it for the fun, but for the money to survive. It's horrible, and I feel sorry for them

    Hope you had fun though!!!

    Lauren,
    Laurensbeautydepartment.blogspot.com

    Xx

    ReplyDelete
  23. First of all, love the sunnies. Secondly, I agree with you on the prostitution thing. I HATE hearing stories of girls being trafficked in the USA- they are literally lured here from other countries. It is so sad and terrible to hear about what they go through.

    ReplyDelete
  24. @kristen- i dont think anyone here is saying amsterdam isnt awesome? I LOVED it there. such an amazing city. this is simply one of a couple posts ill be doing on amsterdam. But seeing as it is one of few places in the world that has prostitution and marjiuana legalized, it is something that most people want to know/see about..especially those in or from the USA (like myself)..which is a country very far removed from the rest of the world. And i dont think the RLD is a touristy place..yes tourist go there because it is fascinating..but i would not call it a tourist destination..like you said, these women are working, and real men go there to pay for their services. And while they can stand their own, most of them are there against their will.

    I will definitely be talking on the "brighter?" side of amsterdam tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Beautiful pictures! You and your fiance look so natural! Haha. I'd probably look like a tourist!

    Hope you check out my giveaway! :)

    Lauren
    http://laurensweetnothings.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  26. It's when you write posts like this one that I realize how much I live vicariously through your blog, I feel like I just visited the red light district, all thanks to you! Great point of view, I agree about prostitution being everywhere, we just choose to see whatever we want and pretend we're blind other times.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I totally went! haha I mean, how can you not walk through the red light district at night while in Am? haha I felt the exact same way! It was like a Halloween exhibit. It wasn't like what I thought it would be. It was so odd to see them on display like that in the windows? haha I agree though, thought it would feel weirder then it did. I was just trying not to get caught looking to much haha it was like "I want to see this... but I don't want anyone to think I am into this or interested?" haha Oh man... def an experiance! &yes, there were tons of couples and women when I went too!

    ReplyDelete
  28. i was SHOCKED when i saw the red light district. i expected dirty, empty, creepy, dark, get me out of here type of place. but i didn't feel like it was that at all.

    ReplyDelete
  29. i went to the red light district during my contiki trip last summer and actually our tour guide told us how over the last few years more and more of the windows that the prostitutes rent out are being bought and taken over by actual businesses in an attempt to sort of clean up the area...not that it's dirty by even NYC standards, but still

    the creepiest thing i did in amsterdam was go to see a live sex show (!!!!) our guide told us about it and told us the most famous place to go to so most of us went, but i am basically the biggest prude of all time...i literally have never even watched a porn ... but i went to this show. but it was just surreal almost, and ridiculous ... those people do the same crazy acts 7x a night!!! ... that it was not even what i think about when i think about sex. hahah!!

    also, i didn't partake in any coffeeshops either. just seems scary to get messed up in a city i dont know (when i dont do that at home either)!

    glad you guys had (are having?) a great time!

    ReplyDelete
  30. I lived 20 minutes out of Amsterdam for 7 months and was there constantly. I figured I'd stay away from that area as well, but as you mentioned it's safer and not as scary as one might expect. It was interesting and just the thing that got to me is that they lived in those tiny apartments, and had little alarm clocks beside their beds. I was there on Christmas Eve and literally every curtain was drawn as every single woman was working on a night where men are lonely. Very interesting concept, but it's just a part of Amsterdam, just like the canals and the weed, which true there is plenty of and just seems to linger in the air.

    ReplyDelete
  31. This is a great post. I love Amsterdam. It's suck a unique city. I've only been 3 times, but I remember going as a 14 year old with my dad and visiting the Anne Frank house. There were red light shops across the street from the museum/house and I mentioned it to my dad. His view was really similar to yours. It is what it is.
    It brings to light some terrible issues with humanity. However, in reality, prostitution is quite an ancient career. As a matter of fact, like you, I'm fascinated by how open Amsterdam is with it. I feel very uncomfortable around those red light windows, and I've always been either shocked at how sick the women look, or, quite the contrary, beautiful they look. It's quite amazing.

    ReplyDelete
  32. When G has had to go to Singapore, he was saddened by all the western men and the young girls in the hotel.

    His taxi driver had porn dvd's sitting next to his seat that he would watch when he didn't have passengers. Its all over. Its huge there and its sad and sickening all the trafficking that goes on and the men that 'fund' it to continue.
    Emily at Amazing Grapes

    ReplyDelete
  33. Ugh, this breaks my heart. Something that fascinates me as well. My church in Seattle was very much apart of trying to end this in the ports of Seattle. So, so sad. Thanks for sharing about the reality of the situation. And lovely photos of the city. Can't wait to hear about more of your time there.

    ReplyDelete
  34. An interesting post Megan - and great that you can be so honest. I think many of us would be curious but some too shy or too 'good' to investigate further...

    I haven't been but my husband went when on tour and he was shocked and horrified yet also intrigued at this other world that is out there... We can't be naive and ignore that this world exists!!

    I would definitely like to visit one day and see what is going on, as well as read up about the origins and history.
    x
    Caley - www.ellieloveblog.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  35. @Lauren- it definitely seems like a career of survival. I mean i have seen shows (so who knows really how accurate it is) about women who love being in the sex industry...

    ReplyDelete
  36. WOW! I didn't even know that's why it is called the redlight district. I feel smarter now... so thank you for that. Also, this whole post basically made me feel like I need to travel.


    CarissaExplainsItAll

    ReplyDelete
  37. I love a good Sodom and Gomorrah reference. You're too funny, girl.

    I don't even know where to begin. I've always been a big believer in harm reduction ie . safe-injection sites, legalization of prostitution etc. but I completely understand the latter, while making their chosen method of work easier for some, does make human trafficking easier. I think that does need to be recognized, legalization does exist for a reason and even if it isn't something you or others (that isn't meant in a snide way, I definitely wouldn't participate or indulge myself) morally agree with, I don't believe policy and laws should be based on moral principles beyond what is best for those it most affects. I don't have an answer, I wish there wasn't some sort of weird tradeoff. But as long as people are actively thinking and educating themselves and others, I believe the best decisions can be made.

    I know it was an aside, but you brought up the idea that Western women parade around in little clothing to satisfy the male gaze. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but that seemed to blame the women rather than the men for placing those expectations on themselves. While it isn't something I usually do, I still support a woman's right to choose what she wants to do with her body regardless of whether it would be my personal choice.

    That's just my personal opinion. I hope this appears to be as respectful as I meant it. My morals are much the same as yours, so I completely respect them. Thanks for sharing about an important issues, I know this isn't a political or activist related blog but I think the fact that isn't makes this reach a broader audience who might not otherwise have known about it.

    ReplyDelete
  38. @Julia- thank you for such a thoughtful comment. I am in no way disrespected by what you said, because your views are VERY much like my own. I can see how my comment could come off the way you interpreted, and i in NO way was trying to put any blame on the women...women have every right to use their beauty, brains, body, etc however they please. I was trying to more so "de-taboo" (word?) the red light district by comparing it to any western city like Los Angeles on saturday night, because people tend to think the RLD is such a foreign idea, and stuff that happens there only happens in europe etc...they would never be caught dead there "participating" in the sin...when really it happens everywhere, all of the time, it just appears in different ways, so who are we to judge?

    My only qualm, like you said, is the trafficking. That is what breaks my heart, but it happens in places where prostitution is legalized and not legal..so what is the solution?

    I responded in a commment to another blogger in e mail here saying ive seen documentaries, read articles etc about women who LOVE working in the sex industry..not all women working as prostitutes are trafficked..but i would say that the majority are working as a result of unfortunate circumstances.

    again, thanks for such a thoughtful and respectful comment!

    ReplyDelete
  39. My parents lived in AMS for almost 10 years and let me just tell you, the RLD is much more mellow than it used to be. Those windows that now have clothing on display? They were ALL filled with women. While there are instances of trafficking, the majority of the women in the main district are there by choice. They make a TON of money. Far more than what they could make at a business in the Netherlands.


    Amsterdam is such a beautiful city, I absolutely love it there and miss it so much. The RLD is such a small portion of what the city has to offer. The canals are lovely, the architecture is amazing, the history (Anne Frank House) is deep. It's just an amazing place that unfortunately evokes a lot misconceptions. Yes, there's legalized marijuana, yes, there's legalized prostitution, but like you mentioned, MANY places in Europe also have these things but not a lot of people realize it.

    If you're ever back in Amsterdam, I would highly suggest visiting the live sex show at the Casa Rosso. I'm sure you saw it when you were strolling in the RLD. It has the pink elephant neon sign out front. It is not nearly as risque as you may think. As a matter of fact, my then 85 year old Mormon grandmother attended a show. It's classy if you can believe that and a great experience.

    ReplyDelete
  40. I spent last weekend in Amsterdam and also took a little walk around the red light district. And I know that prostitution is everwhere, but I was still shocked. Standing in what can only be described as a "shopping window", wearing basically nothing...it felt so wrong! Most of the girls were so pretty and looked..."normal". Not like the typical image you have of a prostitute at all (apart from their clothes of course, or lack thereof).

    I read that the red light district is supposed to be safe nowadays, but I did not feel safe at all! With all these drunk men around me, and there was one time where we were stuck and couldn't move at all.

    Honestly, I wanted to get our of there as fast as possible!

    ReplyDelete
  41. I've never been there but it looks from the pictures that it's beautiful! It also sounds like it's a lot of fun and definitely interesting! Glad you had fun in the red light district.

    ReplyDelete
  42. I think it's cool that you experienced that. I had NO IDEA what the red light district was like until just now, reading your post. INSANE that the women are in shopping windows like that. IN.SANE. What a crazy world we live in! Enjoyed hearing your thoughts on it.

    ReplyDelete
  43. I think it's cool that you experienced that. I had NO IDEA what the red light district was like until just now, reading your post. INSANE that the women are in shopping windows like that. IN.SANE. What a crazy world we live in! Enjoyed hearing your thoughts on it.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you so much for taking the time to comment! I read and try to respond to every one! I will either respond in the comment section or directly through e mail :)

Pin It button on image hover